Will WM Morrison bid put investor ESG credentials to the test?

Big corporate news over the weekend revolves around directors of WM Morrison recommending the 254p per share bid from Fortress. Not only is this around a 10% uplift from the previous offer made by CD&R – another US private equity firm – but it also comes with a raft of promises to protect multiple caveats of the business. WM Morrison owns rather than rents much of its estate, and is also recognised for its commitment to supporting British food producers, especially farmers. The Fortress bid comes with assorted pledges to maintain the status quo here, but are these worth the paper they’re written on? After all, even informal market watchers will still be aware of the high-profile incident when Cadbury was bought by Kraft back in 2010. It promised to keep UK manufacturing sites open – that didn’t last.

So, the prospect now is that further offers will be flushed out, as it seems clear there’s a bargain to be had, here. Another private equity group – Apollo – is rumoured to be looking around in a move which has sent the Morrison’s share price well above levels the bid from Fortress reflects. Investors could soon be asked to show their true colours. Accept a lower priced – but still generous 18 times earnings – offer from a consortium who are pledging to look after staff and suppliers, or accept a higher price from someone with what could be considered a more traditional approach when it comes to return on investment?

Unless those pledges made by Fortress are somehow made irrevocably binding and won’t simply see parts or all of the business being sold on in due course, are investors really wise to buy into promises of good corporate citizenship from what will become a private company with no true external influence on its direction? As much as it pains me to say it, perhaps the wise money takes the highest price on the table then uses the proceeds to find a new investment with values that align with their own.

Read More From CrowdX

Market commentary: The Ecotricity bid on Good Energy

The attempt by Ecotricity to buy out Good Energy has been trundling along since the summer. It’s a hostile bid ...

Trustpilot CTO/CPO Stephen Garland joins CrowdX board

We're delighted to announce the appointment of Stephen Garland to our Board of Directors. As we addresses the challenge facing ...

CrowdX welcomes HM Treasury consultation

HM Treasury has launched a consultation on the regulations surrounding the publication of prospectuses ahead of debt or equity issuance. ...

Paul Atkinson joins CrowdX as Chairman

We’re delighted to announce that Paul Atkinson has been appointed a Chairman of CrowdX. Paul has a recognised track record of ...

“But, isn’t it just easier to use debt?”

How to fund that next round of expansion is an almost inevitable challenge faced by the vast majority of growth ...

Welcome to CrowdX

Unbeknown to many, start-up, growth and scale-up (SG&S) businesses have had a large part to play in changing the equity ...
people gathered around a desk working

Five reasons to list on CrowdX

Early investors in a start-up, growth and scale-up (SG&S) businesses are the heroes of our businesses: they take a chance ...